A fairer go? Improving NDIS equity for culturally diverse communities in Australia
Australia’s National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) is undergoing another phase of significant reforms. Today’s post from researchers at the University of Melbourne – Humaira Maheen, Alex Devine, Peter Summers and Elizabeth Giovannitti-Nowak – and Tri Nguyen and Tadgh McMahon from SSI (a national NGO working with migrants and refugees) argues for a renewed focus on equity in NDIS reforms, in particular for culturally diverse communities.
Concerns about equity in the NDIS have long been flagged. In the decade since its establishment, advocates, the Disability Royal Commission (DRC) and researchers have documented gaps for different cohorts of people with disability. In this article, we draw on our research to explore how people with disability from Culturally and Linguistically Diverse (CALD) backgrounds are faring in the NDIS.
Our findings draw attention to disparities, especially in terms of eligibility and access, underscoring the need for navigation support for CALD communities to strengthen equity, as proposed by the recent independent NDIS Review.
Our multicultural society needs better responses at the intersection of disability and diversity
Australia is more diverse than ever before. The 2021 Census reported that just under half of the population are migrants or have a parent born overseas, and over 5.5 million people speak a language other than English in the home.
A 2018 evaluation of the NDIS by the National Institute of Labour Studies found that, while overall it had improved the lives of people with disability, it had also left several cohorts – including people from CALD backgrounds – no better off or in a worse situation. Since then, advocates, the DRC and research have continued to highlight multiple intersecting barriers for people with disability from CALD backgrounds in engaging with the NDIS.
These long-canvassed barriers include a lack of accessible information in community languages, a lack of culturally responsive mainstream and disability services, and community stigma around disability. There are also gaps in understanding what specialised disability services in Australia can offer in situations where migrants’ countries of origin do not have disability services, or where services that do exist are radically different.
It is the responsibility of Australia’s service systems to be accessible to the diversity of people with disability. Indeed, the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) recognises diversity of people with disability and intersecting forms of exclusion, including race, language, religion, ethnic or indigenous origin.
Our research indicates the NDIS is falling short in responding to cultural diversity
We examined disability among people from CALD backgrounds and their engagement with the NDIS through analysis of the Australian Bureau of Statistics Survey of Disability, Ageing and Carers, NDIS data, a scoping review of peer-reviewed literature, and roundtables with people with lived experience and sector stakeholders.
ABS data indicate that disability prevalence among people aged under 65 is lower in CALD than in non-CALD populations (9% vs 17%), though the proportion of profound disability among people with disability in CALD populations is higher (17% vs 15%). Physical disabilities are more common (67% vs 59%), with a lower proportion of learning disabilities (14% vs 29%).
In addition, CALD populations rely more on informal-only (i.e. family, friends and other unpaid carers) supports (25% vs 19%) and were less likely to combine informal and formal assistance (17% vs 25%). CALD populations were also more likely to say they did not know a service existed (6% vs 4%).
Compared to non-CALD Australians, our analysis indicates a lower proportion of people with disability from CALD backgrounds applied for the NDIS (23% vs 31%). An even lower proportion become NDIS participants (16% vs 24%).
According to NDIS data, once accepted, CALD participants receive larger NDIS plan budgets (median $44,800 vs $35,100) and use a higher share of their allocated funding. Higher use of allocated funding, however, does not necessarily mean effective utilisation or better outcomes. It may reflect a selection effect (the best-supported applicants reaching the NDIS), greater need after delayed access, costs associated with interpreting, or NDIS provider pricing practices.
Navigators could help to improve equity in the NDIS
Findings from our scoping review and roundtable discussions illustrated factors that may contribute to the disparities we found in eligibility and access to the NDIS.
At the eligibility stage, demanding and complex application processes are very difficult to navigate with limited English. Diagnostic evidence can be costly to obtain, and overseas diagnoses may not always meet NDIS requirements. Settlement, multicultural and refugee services often try to help people through this stage but are under-resourced for this work.
At the access stage, limited understanding of the NDIS, stigma, and family expectations can get in the way of help-seeking. NDIS terminology can be hard to understand, even when translated, and low trust in government institutions can limit engagement.
People with disability do not fit neatly into just one category or need just one service system. For many people with disability from CALD backgrounds and their families, they are navigating disability, health, education, housing and other supports simultaneously.
The 2023 NDIS Review recognised this. It recommended resourcing navigators to support people with disability, including those who aren’t on the NDIS. Navigators would help with access to both mainstream and NDIS service systems, alongside foundational supports that are currently being established through the Thriving Kids program nationally.
The Review proposed funding navigators in local communities who have genuine connections with and links to local services, and can act as trusted community intermediaries. This includes resourcing specialist navigators for people with more complex needs and/or from diverse communities. If adequately resourced to work across systems, navigators could support people with disability from CALD backgrounds to find out about and apply to the NDIS and help people who become NDIS participants to effectively utilise their NDIS funding.
This accords with other SSI research with refugees with disability. In that research, Adnan talked about his brother, Yazan:
NDIS should … have a team that meets this person and sees the needs of this person directly, and to help – manage or help the family to find the proper provider. Because we don’t know … as a refugee we came with no knowledge, no experience.
While the NDIS Review provides an outline and explains the potential advantages of navigation support, people with disability from CALD backgrounds should be actively involved in their co-design. Their lived experience should be central to creating a fairer go for culturally diverse communities in the NDIS.
Post moderated by Dr Sophie Yates